top of page


Elden Ring cover art featuring a knight pulling a sword from rock.
Image via Bandai Namco

In the grand tapestry of video game history, few titles have sparked as much intrigue, debate, and admiration as FromSoftware's Elden Ring. This epic creation has stormed the gaming arena, wielding a blend of mythic storytelling and innovative gameplay that challenges the very boundaries of the RPG genre.

After its release, the question lingers, whispered in gaming forums and passionately debated among enthusiasts: Is Elden Ring one of the greatest games of all time? This isn't just a query about technical prowess or artistic merit; it's a deeper, more profound inquiry into the soul of gaming itself.

Elden Ring has undeniably left an indelible mark on the gaming landscape. Its sprawling, open-world design, intricate combat mechanics, and a narrative as enigmatic as it is captivating have set new benchmarks. But does it ascend to the pantheon of the greatest, standing shoulder to shoulder with the legends of yesteryears?

In this exploration, we delve into the heart of what makes Elden Ring a contender for this coveted title. From its hype and anticipation to its gameplay mechanics, from its visual and auditory artistry to the controversies it stirred, we'll journey through the Lands Between to uncover the essence of Elden Ring's claim to greatness.

Follow the Ape Odyssey blog to stay updated with gaming trends, reviews and strategy guides.

Elden Ring: A Journey from Myth to Reality

The story of Elden Ring's ascent begins not with its release but in the swirling mists of anticipation that preceded it. This was a game shrouded in mystery, its development cloaked in silence, punctuated by whispers and rumors that only served to fuel the fires of expectation.

The Unconventional Path to Stardom

Unlike many of its contemporaries, Elden Ring's journey to the public eye was anything but ordinary. Announced at E3 2019 with a tantalizing teaser, it then vanished into a void of speculation. This atypical marketing approach, marked by long periods of silence and sporadic updates, created a unique form of hype. It wasn't just anticipation; it was a hunger, a collective yearning for something monumental.

The Power of Delayed Gratification

Elden Ring's delayed gratification played a masterstroke. Each delay, each missed event, paradoxically added to the game's allure. The community's imagination ran wild, crafting theories and memes, filling the void with their own narratives and expectations. This wasn't just a game waiting to be released; it was a legend in the making.

The Crescendo of Launch

When Elden Ring finally emerged, it was like a dam bursting. The pent-up anticipation overflowed into a spectacular launch. The game's release wasn't just a date on the calendar; it was a cultural event, a moment where the gaming world collectively held its breath and then exhaled in awe.

In this backdrop of unprecedented hype and anticipation, Elden Ring had set the stage for itself. But the question remained: could it live up to the colossal expectations it had unwittingly crafted? 

Gameplay and Mechanics: Redefining the RPG Experience

At the heart of Elden Ring's claim to greatness lies its gameplay and mechanics, a symphony of innovation and tradition that has both captivated and challenged players worldwide. This section delves into the elements that make Elden Ring's gameplay not just compelling but potentially groundbreaking in the realm of RPGs.

A fiery scene from Elden Ring gameplay.
Image via Bandai Namco

1. A Seamless Blend of Open-World Exploration and Tactical Combat

Elden Ring takes players through the Lands Between, a vast, open world teeming with secrets, dangers, and wonders. This expansive landscape breaks free from linear storytelling, offering a sandbox of exploration where every hill, every ruin, and every shadowed corner can hold a new adventure. The game's open-world design is not just about scale; it's about depth and interactivity, where the environment itself becomes a character in the player's story.

2. Combat: A Dance of Strategy and Skill

The soul of Elden Ring lies in its combat system – a meticulous blend of strategy, skill, and adaptability. FromSoftware's signature challenging combat is elevated with new mechanics, such as mounted battles and a more nuanced stealth system. Each encounter, whether with the lowliest grunt or the mightiest boss, is a test of the player's understanding of the game's intricate combat language.

3. Legacy of FromSoftware: Evolution or Revolution?

Elden Ring stands on the shoulders of its predecessors – the Soulsborne games. It takes the best elements from these classics and weaves them into something familiar yet fresh. The question arises: Is Elden Ring an evolution of the formula, or is it a revolution? The game certainly retains the challenging core that fans adore, but it also introduces elements that make it more accessible to newcomers, striking a delicate balance between tradition and innovation.

4. The Role of Player Choice and Build Diversity

One of Elden Ring's most lauded aspects is the freedom it offers in character builds and playstyles. The game encourages experimentation, allowing players to tailor their journey to their preferences, whether they prefer brute force, cunning magic, or a mix of both. This level of customization adds layers of replayability and personalization, making each player's journey through the Lands Between uniquely their own.

It's a game that respects its lineage while daring to chart new territories in the RPG genre. As we turn our gaze to the visual and auditory artistry of the Elden Ring, the picture of its claim to the throne of gaming greatness becomes even clearer.

Visuals, Sound, and Atmosphere: The Artistry of Elden Ring

Elden Ring's journey to greatness is not just carved by its gameplay but also painted with its stunning visuals and sound. This section explores how the game's artistry contributes to creating a world that's not only immersive but also emotionally resonant.

1. A Visual Feast for the Eyes

Elden Ring's visual design is a masterclass in fantasy world-building. From the hauntingly beautiful vistas of the Lands Between to the grotesque elegance of its creatures, the game is a tapestry of artistic brilliance. The attention to detail in environments, the play of light and shadow, and the use of color all come together to create a world that is as breathtaking as it is daunting. It's a world where every frame could be a painting, telling its own silent story.

2. Sound Design: The Unseen Narrator

The game's sound design is a subtle yet powerful force in shaping the player's experience. The rustle of leaves, the distant roar of a dragon, the melancholic notes of a lute – all these sounds breathe life into the Lands Between. The soundtrack, with its epic orchestral scores and haunting melodies, elevates the emotional impact of the game, turning battles into sagas and explorations into odysseys.

3. Atmosphere: A Symphony of Senses

Elden Ring's true artistry lies in its ability to create an atmosphere that engulfs the player. It's a world where beauty and terror walk hand in hand, where wonder and dread are two sides of the same coin. The game's environments are not just backdrops; they are characters in their own right, each with a story to tell, a secret to whisper. This atmospheric depth makes the Lands Between feel like a living, breathing entity, one that players are compelled to explore and understand.

A screenshot of the majestic fantasy world of Elden Ring.
Image via Bandai Namco

4. The Role of Art in Storytelling

In Elden Ring, art is not just a visual treat; it's an integral part of the storytelling. The game's lore is woven into its landscapes, architecture, and even the design of its enemies. This visual storytelling invites players to delve deeper, to look beyond the surface, and uncover the rich tapestry of myths and legends that form the backbone of the game's narrative.

In examining the visual and auditory artistry of Elden Ring, we see a game that transcends the traditional boundaries of gaming. It's a work of art that invites players to lose themselves in a world that captivates the senses and stirs the soul. 

Navigating the Shadows: Addressing Elden Ring's Criticisms

While Elden Ring has been lauded for its many triumphs, it has not been without its share of criticisms and controversies. This section explores the common critiques that have surfaced, providing a balanced view of the game's reception.

1. The Challenge of Accessibility

A significant point of contention is the game's difficulty level. Elden Ring, in keeping with FromSoftware's legacy, presents a steep challenge, which, while appealing to many, can be a barrier to others. Critics argue that its unforgiving nature and lack of adjustable difficulty settings may alienate players who are not accustomed to such rigorous gameplay.

2. Technical Performance Issues

Despite its artistic achievements, Elden Ring has faced criticism for technical issues, particularly on certain platforms. Players have reported performance problems like frame rate drops and graphical glitches, which, for some, detract from the overall experience.

3. The Double-Edged Sword of Open-World Design

While the game's vast open world is a highlight for many, others have found it overwhelming or lacking in direction. The sheer size and freedom can sometimes lead to a sense of aimlessness, contrasting with the more structured environments of previous FromSoftware titles.

4. Balancing Lore and Clarity

Elden Ring's storytelling, rich in lore and mystery, has been both praised and criticized. Some players find the cryptic narrative and environmental storytelling deeply engaging, while others feel it lacks clarity and cohesiveness.

These criticisms highlight the challenges faced by Elden Ring in balancing its ambitious vision with the diverse preferences of its audience. They serve as a reminder that even the most celebrated games are not without their imperfections.

Elden Ring's Place in Gaming History: A New Chapter in the Annals of Gaming

As we reflect on Elden Ring's journey and its reception, both laudatory and critical, it's time to consider its place in the annals of gaming history.

1. A Benchmark for Future Titles

Elden Ring has undoubtedly set a new benchmark for open-world games and RPGs. Its blend of storytelling, gameplay mechanics, and artistic design has raised the bar, offering a template that future titles will likely aspire to.

2. Influencing Game Design and Narrative

The game's impact extends beyond its immediate achievements. It has influenced the conversation around game design, particularly in how open-world games can be structured and how narratives can be woven into gameplay and environment.

A game developer working on his computer.

3. A Testament to Creative Collaboration

The collaboration between Hidetaka Miyazaki and George R.R. Martin in creating Elden Ring's world is a testament to the power of creative minds coming together. It highlights the potential of cross-disciplinary collaborations in enriching video game narratives and universes.

4. A Cultural Phenomenon

Beyond its gameplay, Elden Ring has become a cultural phenomenon. It has sparked discussions, fan theories, artwork, and a community of players dedicated to unraveling its mysteries. This cultural footprint is indicative of its impact and longevity in the gaming world.

Elden Ring: A Legendary Contender in the Gaming Pantheon

As we close our exploration of Elden Ring’s status in gaming history, we return to the question that sparked this odyssey: Is Elden Ring one of the greatest games of all time? The journey through its landscapes, mechanics, artistry, and the chorus of voices from critics and fans alike brings us to a nuanced answer.

Elden Ring is undeniably a masterpiece of modern gaming. It has pushed the boundaries of what an open-world RPG can be, blending meticulous gameplay, breathtaking visuals, and a narrative depth that has captivated a diverse audience. Its influence on game design and the cultural impact it has made are undeniable marks of its greatness.

However, the title of "the greatest game of all time" is subjective, colored by individual experiences, preferences, and gaming histories. Elden Ring, for many, will hold this esteemed title – a game that redefined genres, challenged players, and offered a world of unparalleled depth and beauty. For others, its imperfections – the steep difficulty curve, technical issues, and narrative obscurity – might place it just shy of the pinnacle.

In the end, Elden Ring stands not just as a game but as a landmark in gaming history. It is a testament to the artistry and innovation possible in this medium, a source of inspiration for future game developers, and a game that will be remembered, discussed, and revered for years to come.

Whether it is "the greatest" may be a matter of personal interpretation, but its legacy as one of the most extraordinary games ever crafted is unquestionable. Elden Ring has not just entered the pantheon of great games; it has etched its name in it with a bold stroke, inviting players to experience a world where fantasy and reality blur into an unforgettable adventure. So what do you think? Is Elden Ring one of the greatest games of all time?


bottom of page